City Stroller or All-Terrain Stroller? What I Learned Owning Both

Watercolor of a compact city stroller and a three-wheel all-terrain stroller side by side, with a cat between them
This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read our disclosure

I loved my first stroller. And I sold it anyway.

Shopping Black Friday? See my picks →

My Babyzen YOYO2 was perfect for Raf’s first months: tiny, light and so easy to fold. But once I recovered from postpartum and wanted to run again, it just wasn’t the right tool anymore. So I sold it and bought a Mountain Buggy Swift, an all-terrain stroller that comes with me everywhere today.

Owning both taught me something no product page will tell you: there’s no “best stroller.” There’s the best stroller for the life you actually live. In this post I’ll share the real numbers, how each one worked month by month, where each one won and failed, and 6 questions that will help you choose.

The Short Answer

  • Choose a compact city stroller (like the YOYO2) if you live in a city, walk on smooth sidewalks, use public transport or fly often, and have little storage space.
  • Choose an all-terrain stroller (like the Mountain Buggy Swift) if you walk on dirt, grass, gravel or the beach, take long walks, or want to run with your baby once they’re old enough.

Not sure? Start with the life you have now. A good stroller holds its value, so you can sell it and switch later, like I did.

The Numbers Side by Side

Babyzen YOYO2Mountain Buggy Swift
TypeCompact city / travel strollerCompact all-terrain stroller (3 wheels)
Weight6.2 kg (13.6 lb) with the 6+ seat7.6 kg (16.8 lb)
Folded size52 × 44 × 18 cm (20.5 × 17.3 × 7.1 in)Standing fold: 93 × 58 × 35 cm (36.6 × 22.8 × 13.8 in). Without the wheels, it folds flatter: 79 × 46 × 33 cm (31.1 × 18.1 × 13 in)
Fits in the plane cabinYes, on most airlinesNo, it goes in the hold
WheelsSmall wheels10-inch air-filled tires
AgeFrom birth with the bassinet or newborn packFrom birth to about 4 years
Max child weight22 kg (48.5 lb)22 kg (48.5 lb)
ReclineGoodLies completely flat
BasketUp to 5 kg (11 lb), and more spaceUp to 5 kg (11 lb), but less space
FoldOne handEasy, but I always use two hands
HandlebarMine didn’t adjust in heightAdjusts from 57 to 106 cm (22.4 to 41.7 in)
Best onSmooth sidewalks, malls, buses, airportsDirt, grass, gravel, beach, broken sidewalks

Specs from the Babyzen and Mountain Buggy websites. Models change over time, so check the current version before you buy.

My Year With Two Strollers, Month by Month

0 to 5 months: the YOYO with the bassinet. I used the YOYO with its newborn bassinet from day one. Raf slept lying flat, and I used every nap to go for a walk or run errands. It was compact, practical and adapted to almost every situation of our everyday life.

Babyzen YOYO2 stroller with the newborn bassinet at home

Around 5 months: from the bassinet to the seat. Raf was getting too big for the bassinet, so I switched to the regular YOYO seat, fully reclined. Our pediatricians and our physical therapist told me it’s important to respect each baby’s timing for sitting up, and not to put them in a seated position before they’re ready. So the seat stayed reclined until Raf was ready.

Our baby napping in the Babyzen YOYO2 seat, fully reclined, face hidden for privacy

After postpartum: I wanted to run again. Once I felt recovered, I wanted to go back to running, and the YOYO’s small wheels weren’t made for that. After a long time comparing what was on the market, the Mountain Buggy Swift felt like the best value for the price. I sold my YOYO and bought it.

Selling it was the easy part. I sold it with all its accessories (the bassinet, the rain cover, the parasol, the cup holder, a small bag, the travel bag and the bumper bar), it went very quickly, and that money paid for my new running stroller.

9 months: our first run together. We went on our first run when Raf was 9 months old, once my little one had strong head and neck control. Today we usually run 6 to 10 km (about 4 to 6 miles) on paved streets.

A mom kneeling next to her baby in a black Mountain Buggy Swift all-terrain stroller, with faces hidden for privacy

Our trip to Europe: the Mountain Buggy plus a baby carrier. I took the Mountain Buggy on our trip to Europe, and it was the right call. We visited those typical medieval villages with tiny cobblestones, uneven ground and narrow streets that go up and down all the time. The Mountain Buggy handled all of it.

Our toddler standing next to the Mountain Buggy Swift in front of an old cathedral during our trip to Europe, face hidden for privacy

Real Life Tests: Where Each One Won

A day in the city

Winner: YOYO. The YOYO folded with one hand, was easy to take anywhere in the city, and its basket held more than the Mountain Buggy’s. If your days are errands, buses and sidewalks, it’s hard to beat.

Broken sidewalks, grass, dirt and the beach

Winner: Mountain Buggy. This is where the YOYO struggled. Every time we hit a broken piece of sidewalk, it got complicated: it simply wasn’t made for bumpy paths. The Mountain Buggy, with its big air-filled tires, rolls over grass, dirt, gravel and sand. And it’s so easy to steer that I can push it with one hand.

At the airport

Winner: YOYO, if you want it in the cabin. The YOYO folds small enough to be accepted as cabin luggage on most airlines. I’ve seen families board with it, although I always checked mine in the hold. The Mountain Buggy always goes in the hold.

My trick for both: I board with my baby carrier. I got on the plane and off the plane with my baby in the carrier, so I never got tired waiting for the stroller. Some airlines hand it back at the plane door, others at baggage claim, so the carrier saved me every time. (Here’s the carrier that saved our trip to Europe.)

Naps on the go

Winner: Mountain Buggy. It reclines completely flat and its canopy gives more shade. The YOYO has a parasol you can buy as an accessory, but I found it really complicated to use.

For the Mountain Buggy, you can also buy two covers that make a big difference: a sun cover with UV protection, to keep the sun off your baby, and a blackout cover for naps and sleepy moments on the go.

If your stroller’s own sun protection falls short, like the YOYO parasol did for me, a universal stroller sun shade is an easy fix. Look for one with UPF 50+ that covers the whole front of the stroller and still lets air through. Here are some universal stroller sun shades on Amazon.

One important safety note: never cover the stroller with a blanket or a muslin cloth, because heat builds up inside. Use a cover made for strollers, with breathable mesh, and check on your baby often on hot days.

The Babyzen YOYO2 with its parasol accessory and the basket underneath

Running

Winner: Mountain Buggy, by far. The YOYO is not made for running. With the Mountain Buggy, Raf and I run 6 to 10 km on paved streets, and we also take it on long walks, on trails and to the beach. It has a wrist strap for safety, a bottle holder and a handlebar that adjusts from 57 to 106 cm (22.4 to 41.7 in), which is handy if you share the stroller with someone taller or shorter. Its rain cover is sold separately too, and I really recommend it.

The car trunk

Tie. Both fit in my car’s trunk. The YOYO takes almost no space; the Mountain Buggy is bigger, but it still fits without any problem.

What Nobody Tells You

  • The harness on my Mountain Buggy needs to be really snug. If it’s even a little loose, a wiggly baby can slip out of it. I check it every single time.
  • I wish both had a seat that could face me. When Raf was little, I would have loved to keep eye contact during our walks.
  • I wish the Mountain Buggy were a little smaller when folded. It’s compact for an all-terrain stroller, but it’s nothing like the YOYO.
  • Accessories add up. The covers I use most on the Mountain Buggy were sold separately, so include them in your budget.
  • Air-filled tires roll beautifully, but remember to check the pressure from time to time.

6 Questions to Help You Choose

If I could go back, I’d do one thing differently: research more on my own. I chose my first stroller based on what the people close to me recommended, without really thinking about my own routine. These are the questions I wish I had asked myself:

  • Where will you walk most? Smooth sidewalks and malls: a compact stroller. Dirt, grass, sand or broken sidewalks: an all-terrain one.
  • Do you have a car? If you take buses or the subway, a light stroller that folds with one hand will make your life easier.
  • Will you fly with your baby? If you want the stroller in the cabin, check that its folded size is accepted as cabin luggage.
  • No time to exercise? You can run with your baby. You’ll need a stroller made for running, and you can start when your baby is around 6 to 8 months old (ask your pediatrician first).
  • How much space do you have at home and in the car? Measure your trunk and the spot where the stroller will live.
  • What’s your budget, including resale? Good strollers keep their value. Selling my YOYO, with its accessories, paid for my Mountain Buggy.

My Closest Picks on Amazon

Neither the YOYO nor the Mountain Buggy Swift is sold on Amazon US right now. These are the closest options I’d look at today. I haven’t used them myself, so I chose them for having what I valued most in mine, and thousands of good reviews.

If you want a compact city stroller like the YOYO:

UPPAbaby Minu V3: a premium compact stroller with an easy fold.

Check the UPPAbaby Minu V3 on Amazon →

gb Pockit Air All Terrain: a budget-friendly option that folds super small.

Check the gb Pockit Air on Amazon →

If you want to run with your baby:

BOB Gear Revolution Flex 3.0: a dedicated jogging stroller with a front wheel you can lock for running, and more than 3,000 reviews.

Check the BOB Revolution Flex 3.0 on Amazon →

Safety Tips Before You Run With a Stroller

  • Wait until your baby is ready. Many jogging stroller brands and pediatricians recommend waiting until your baby is around 6 to 8 months old and has strong head and neck control. Ask your pediatrician first.
  • Check your stroller’s manual to make sure it’s approved for running, and lock the front wheel when you run, if your stroller has that option.
  • Always wear the wrist strap.
  • Keep the harness snug and check it before every outing.

The Moments I’ll Always Remember

With the YOYO, I remember our walks when Raf was tiny and slept in the bassinet. I used every nap to go for a walk or run errands, and watching my baby sleep was the sweetest thing.

Our newborn napping in the Babyzen YOYO2 bassinet during a walk, face hidden for privacy

With the Mountain Buggy, I remember our first runs together: how happy Raf was, and how relaxed we both were when we got home.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Babyzen YOYO worth it?

For city life and travel, yes. It’s light, folds with one hand and fits in most plane cabins. If you walk on rough ground or want to run, it’s not the right stroller.

Can you take a YOYO on a plane as carry-on?

Babyzen says its folded size is accepted as cabin luggage by most airlines. Check your airline’s rules before you fly.

When can my baby go in a jogging stroller?

Many brands and pediatricians recommend waiting until around 6 to 8 months, when your baby has strong head and neck control. Ask your pediatrician first. We started at 9 months.

Do I need two strollers?

Not necessarily. Choose the one that fits your life now. Good strollers keep their value, so you can sell one and switch later, like I did.

Can you run with a regular stroller?

It’s not recommended. Running needs a stroller made for it, with a front wheel you can lock, good suspension and a wrist strap. Check your stroller’s manual before you run.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *